BIP-300 biff: Debate reignites over years-old Bitcoin Drivechain proposal

The proposal would allow other blockchains built on the Bitcoin network. In August, a core developer rewrote the proposal's code and requested it be added to Bitcoin's codebase, sparking new debate over its merits.

A debate has reignited among Bitcoiners over a six-year-old Bitcoin Improvement Proposal (BIP) to add “sidechains” on top of the network, with some warning it could increase scams on the Bitcoin network and others saying it will bring new users of the cryptocurrency.

Meanwhile, one developer claims to have found a way to achieve the proposal's goal without a soft fork of the blockchain.

The proposal in question, BIP-300 — also known as Bitcoin (BTC) Drivechains — was first introduced in 2017, which proposed introducing “sidechains” that are separate blockchains on top of the Bitcoin network.

Paul Sztorc, the proposal’s author and founder of the Drivechain development firm LayerTwo Labs which raised $3 million in December, has explained the blockchains would allow for BTC to move onto them and create altcoins.

However, the debate over the proposal was kicked up again when a Bitcoin core developer known as Luke Dashjr rewrote the proposal's code and requested to add it to Bitcoin’s codebase on Aug. 22.

BIP-300 would require a soft fork of Bitcoin that would be activated by miners — not unlike the Taproot soft fork in November 2021 that paved the way for the equally controversial nonfungible token (NFT) emulating Ordinals and BRC-20 tokens that launched earlier this year.

On Sep. 10, Maxim Orlovsky, the CEO of blockchain scaling solutions project Pandora, posted on X (Twitter) claiming he was able to create a two-way peg on Bitcoin without a soft fork of the blockchain which BIP-300 requires.

In an accompanying note Orlovsky explained an old project proposal could work as a BIP-300 alternative with an oracle working to validate a sidechain and "the protocol will reach consensus on whether the state reported by the oracle is correct.”

Details, so far, are sparse. Orlovsky said he would work on a paper describing the setup “in [an] understandable way.”

Meanwhile, BIP-300 proponents including Sztorc argue Drivechains will allow users to choose a blockchain security model they agree with and how they want their Bitcoin to work. Sztorc also claimed the proposal has “enormous upside” with “literally zero downside.”

Related: No, Bitcoin withdrawals from exchanges are not inherently bullish for crypto

Others, including Cory Klippsten, the chief of the BTC-only exchange Swan Bitcoin, rejected the proposal — with Klippsten claiming Drivechains would increase the amount of scams on Bitcoin which may catch the ire of regulators.

Pierre Rochard, the VP of research at Bitcoin miner Riot Platforms said the proposal’s messaging relies on “speculative economic arguments rather than substantive engineering ones” and added it was “pure hopium.”

Others that lent their voice to support BIP-300 included educator Dan Held who claimed that Bitcoin is better off with more speculative assets as they “introduce new audiences to Bitcoin.”

Meanwhile, Bitcoin wallet provider Casa co-founder Jameson Lopp said he’s yet to see a “convincing concern” of how sidechains could be dangerous to the main Bitcoin blockchain.

He added if a sidechain becomes more valuable it could signal that the base chain “should implement that sidechain's features.”

Magazine: Recursive inscriptions — Bitcoin ‘supercomputer’ and BTC DeFi coming soon

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Iran completes pre-pilot phase of central bank digital currency

The Central Bank of Iran progresses with CBDC development in anticipation of the Bank of Russia’s governor Elvira Nabiullina’s visit. Iran is moving forward with its central bank digital currency (CBDC) plans, completing preliminary research for the launch of a potential digital rial. The Central Bank of Iran (CBI) has successfully completed a pre-pilot phase in the development of Iran’s CBDC, according to an official statement by CBI’s research arm, the Monetary and Banking Research Institute (MBRI). Mohammad Reza Mani Yekta, head of the CBI office for supervising payment systems, announced the news at the ninth annual conference on electronic banking and payment systems on Feb. 20. He noted that Iran’s central bank plans to increase the scope of the CBDC pilot in the country’s payment system, but doesn’t want to rush its implementation. “The pre-pilot phase ended successfully with valuable achievements. The project will soon be launched in other ecosystems and will be used by mo...
Read more

5 Cryptocurrencies Outperforming Others in the Top 100

Image
WLD’s successful rise above the $8 resistance could trigger a jump toward $10. AR might slip below $20 while selling pressure could lead PEPE down to $0.0000013. Increased buying pressure could send FET above $2 while FLR’s momentum had turned bearish. Over the last few weeks, the broader crypto market has experienced major upside with Bitcoin (BTC) hitting $64,000 at one point. However, apart from Bitcoin’s jump, there have been several cryptocurrencies that have been in the spotlight and performed exceptionally. Here are the top five best-performing coins in the top 100. Worldcoin (WLD) Worldcoin’s (WLD) price increased by 217.82% in the last 30 days. At a particular time, the price of the token crossed $9. However, in the last seven days, the upward trajectory had cooled, and at press time, Worldcoin changed hands at $7.72. Based on the 4-hour WLD/USD chart sellers might have gotten exhausted with support appearing at $7.25. However, a build-up bac...
Read more

ChatGPT 4-o predicts Solana price amid ETF forecast for 2025

Image
Solana (SOL), currently the fifth-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization, has experienced a notable price jump in the past 24 hours.  This rise is fueled by VanEck, a well-known New York investment management firm, filing an S-1 registration statement for its “VanEck Solana Trust,” marking the first attempt to launch a spot Solana exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the U.S. In addition, Canadian firm 3iQ Corp recently filed a preliminary prospectus to introduce the Solana Fund (QSOL) in Canada. These filings have generated substantial interest and speculation about Solana’s future price trajectory.   Picks for you 3 cryptocurrencies to turn $100 into $1,000 for end of 2024 32 mins ago Here's Bitcoin's ...
Read more